Got thoughts on the 1986 Mets or this newsletter? Please reach out to [email protected]
I will be starting game-by-game playoff coverage on Thursday, with each essay coinciding with the 40th anniversary of that particular game (the essays about the losses will be short!).
In the meantime, let me warm you up for that with something fun. In addition to pursuing last week's interview with Mike Breen, I also spent a few months tracking down Craig Thomas. Craig is the co-creator of the wonderfully innovative TV show How I Met Your Mother, which aired on CBS for nine seasons from 2005 to 2014. Craig has previously written for The Late Show with David Letterman and recently wrote his debut novel, That's Not How It Happened. He also has a podcast with actor/director Josh Radnor, How We Made Your Mother, on which they rewatch and dissect the show with the same intensity that I've rewatched the 1986 Mets.
It's a different kind of rewatch podcast that often gets philosophical and has some deep cut literary references. They don't just dissect scenes. They talk about the nature of love and pursuing goals and all sorts of other things tangentially connected to HIMYM. They like to say they're teaching a doctorate-level class in the show, just like I'm doing with the 1986 Mets.
Most important to us is that Craig is my age and is a huge New York Mets fan. And I was able to get him for an e-mail interview. He's got great stories related to Howard Johnson and Darryl Strawberry, and related well how much the team impacted him. The interview is below.
What is the origin of your Mets fandom and how did that fandom develop?
My father grew up a New York Giants fan. When they left town (breaking his Willie Mays-idolizing heart), it was very important to continue hating the New York Yankees, as was the sworn and sacred duty of all New York Giants fans (not to mention Brooklyn Dodgers fans). So, a few years later, when the Mets came into existence, it was a natural fit for my dad to root for them. I inherited rooting for the underdog. It has, I would argue, profoundly shaped my entire personality.
What did your fandom in 1986 look like? Where were you and how did you react when the ball went through Bill Buckner's legs?
I was 11 years old when that ball rolled through Bill Buckner's legs, and time stopped. The Mets were my team. That team was one of the most important things in the world to me at that moment.
As hard as it can be, speaking in glacial terms, to be a Mets fan, I do feel lucky too: I was the perfect age for the 1986 Mets. How could anything beat that? I remember as things looked grim, late in Game 6 of that World Series—before we knew miracles were in store—I was so heartbroken that I couldn't watch anymore. I left my mom and dad in the TV room and moped up to my bedroom, distraught and convinced the season was over.
But not long after that, my mom or dad (I forget which, but I think maybe my mom) ran up and knocked on my door to say, "You have to come back down...something amazing's happening!" And thank God she did. Because I ran down to the TV and caught up with that 10th inning rally heating up. And my mind proceeded to be blown in a way that it may never be again by any sporting event, ever. Sports will probably never get better for me than that season, than that inning, if I live to be 110 years old. It felt like a miracle.
Did you do/have you ever done any writing about the Mets at any point? (even for things like college essays or class assignments)
Well, in my debut novel which recently came out, That's Not How It Happened, fandom of the New York Mets is actually the "How I Met Your Mother" story for Rob and Paige, the parents in the book. They met at a Mets game, so I guess it's actually a "How I Mets Your Mother" story. (Sorry, had to.)
The character of Rob, a screenwriter, winds up writing a movie called Subway Series—a hit rom-com about a Mets and a Yankees fan falling in love during a Mets-Yankees World Series. There are few quicker or stronger bonds formed than when you meet a fellow fan and long-sufferer. You know that person roots for the underdog and has a highly developed sense of the absurd. But also that they're a person of faith...not necessarily religious faith but the foolish yet beautiful faith that the Mets will actually be good this year. And when that actually happens, I think it brings Mets fans more joy than other teams. Because of the suffering. The Mets aren't part of the plot of my novel, but I do mention them a bunch in the book.
I also once wrote an essay (unpublished) about the time when I was a kid and my aunt got me Howard Johnson's autograph (he had visited the college she worked at on Long Island). I bragged to my friends that next time I saw my aunt, I would receive this legendary autograph. I was so excited, but when she handed me the glossy signed headshot, it said: "To Craig: The Spelling Champ! Howard Johnson." My aunt had told Howard Johnson I had recently won a spelling bee at school. I pictured the conversation. Howard: "Tell me about your nephew!" Aunt: "He's good at spelling!" Howard: "I'll call him a Spelling Champ!" My aunt: "He'll be so proud to show that to all his friends -- I mean, spelling well is a really cool and useful skill!" Howard: "Heck yeah, it is!" {They high-five; Howard signs photo). Yeeeeeeah.......I never showed that autograph to another living soul.
Who have been your favorite Mets? (emphasis on earliest part of your fanhood) Every Mets fan has a lousy player they liked. Who is yours and why?
My non-lousy player is Mookie Wilson. Mookie Wilson is my guy. I loved him well before the Bill Buckner Moment, but that at-bat only added to my adoration. He embodied something about the Mets as a team: Never say never. Never give up. That entire at-bat leading up to The Ground Ball (capital T, capital G, capital B) was an exercise in staying alive; in never giving up; in finding a way. Sure, Buckner made an error. But Mookie made something happen. He found a way. A 10-pitch at bat. Staying in the at-bat until that wild pitch that brough Kevin Mitcell in from 3rd. You don't have to hit a home run every at-bat (and Mookie was not that guy) to be a catalyst. A magician. A guy who finds a way.
I hate to call anybody lousy, but I do have a special place in my heart for those oddball, lower-profile, deep-cut dudes on the '86 Mets. I just enjoy randomly coming up with their names sometimes. Tim Teufel. Kevin Elster. Danny Heep. (I mean, the guy's last name is Heep...heap of what? But in fairness, he was a solid left-hand hitter utility guy!). Ed Hearn. Doug Sisk. (Does Doug Sisk even remember that Doug Sisk was on the '86 Mets?).
Of all those guys, I remember liking Tim Teufel's weird horizontal-ish batting stance and trying to emulate it a bit in Little League. I'm probably the only kid in America who tried to model his swing on Tim Teufel. That may account for my vast success in Little League. (No, in reality, I was probably my team's Tim Teufel...meaning, not half bad! But also not that great.)
I love all those guys. They all ARE the '86 Mets. Scrappy, not showy. You don't have the full set of '86 Mets baseball cards unless you have every single one of those guys' cards too. I mean, the credits at the end of a movie don't just list the names of the movie stars; they list out everybody's name, because without every one of those folks' hard work, there's no movie, #DougSisk4Eva.
Craig and his family are avid supporters of Rady Children's Hospital in San Diego, which studies the genetic basis of pediatric heart defects and cognitive disabilities in children. A link to their work is below.
When you watch baseball, how do you watch it? (as in, what are the things you pay attention to and think about?)
I am an old man who misses complete games by pitchers and gets annoyed by challenges and is absolutely appalled by randomly putting a baserunner on 2nd base in extra innings (how did that phantom runner wind up on 2nd base?!). Yes, I'm a total aging baseball fan cliche. But here we are.
When you look back at the 1986 Mets 40 years later, how do you think of them?
Like a fever dream I once had...Watching your team pull off a miracle does give you this lofty idea that it will be a regular occurrence. Spoilers: It hasn't.
In That's Not How It Happened, you repeatedly reference Subway Series, a romantic story about a Mets fan and a Yankees fan. Does this script actually exist and will it ever see the light of day?
Ha, no it's not a real script. But I've had readers tell me I should really write it. Who knows. Like my man Mookie, never say never!
Where were you and how did you react when Carlos Beltran struck out to end the 2006 NLCS? Were any episodes of HIMYM influenced by a moment in Mets history, good or bad?
I was living in LA at the time and I'm ashamed to say that my Mets fandom fell off at that time, as running How I Met Your Mother took over my life (so I don't have strong memories or emotions of this chapter). But I'm proud to say I was never even slightly tempted to become a Dodgers fan (unlike some other transplanted New Yorkers I know and shall not name here). I'm a lifelong Mets fan even when I'm not living in New York.
One of the HIMYM themes is 'the things people do for love', crazy and otherwise. What's the most ridiculous thing you did as part of your Mets fanhood?
This story isn't me, but my mother. During the 1986 season, the Mets were my religion. They were truly the world to me. For my 11th birthday, in August, my mother surprised me with a gift.
Backstory: I grew up in Port Washington, a suburb of NYC in Long Island. The Port Washington line of the Long Island Railroad is the one with the stop right at Shea Stadium (now Citi Field). As a result, Port Washington had a uniquely strong connection to the Mets, even to the point where a few New York Mets over the years rented houses in and around my hometown.
Rumors would spread, you didn't quite know if they were real. Hey, did you hear Darryl Strawberry rented a place just a few blocks from our school? Of all the rumors that one sounded especially far-fetched. But it turned out to be true. Somebody knew which house. One day, my friends and I rode our bikes by it, just circling the house, and we saw Darryl peek out the curtains at us (probably thinking, "Do I need to call the cops on these stupid kids circling my lawn?). It was like spotting Big Foot or The Loch Ness Monster. Did we really just see that?! But we had. I told my mother about it.
Then, when my birthday rolled around, I opened a present she gave me and it was a baseball signed by Darryl Strawberry. My crazy mother had driven over to his house, knocked on the door, said that her son was a huge fan and would Darryl please sign this baseball? Darryl told her to wait and took the ball inside. She was briefly unsure if now the cops were being called on her. But when he returned, the ball was signed not just by Darryl, but by Lenny Dykstra, who turned out to be visiting Darryl at that exact moment. In the closing line of A Christmas Story, one of my favorite films, Adult Ralphie says, looking back on the BB gun his old man had bought him, that it was "The greatest Christmas gift I had ever received, or would ever receive." That baseball is my Red Ryder BB gun.
Did you sneak in any deep Mets easter eggs into anything you've written - from Letterman to Ali G to How I Met? (besides Barney smoking whenever the Mets are eliminated?) Any characters on anything you've done named after Mets?)
Here and there I've dropped a Mets reference. The biggest are in my book. But I'll admit to a Big Regret: Why in God's name did I not make The Mets somebody's favorite team on How I Met Your Mother?! Or at least set a fun episode at a Mets game. If I'd done that, I might've had this amazing extra connection to the Mets, right?! Maybe they would've asked me to come throw out a first pitch or something. But no. I never wrote that episode. So the Mets never asked. I f*cked that up.
I kind of feel like Teds Mets fandom is implied. There is no way that someone of his personality could be anything other than a Mets fan. The endless pursuit of a goal, the constant letdown with plenty of LOLs along the way, and the undying optimism that this one will be the one.
You're right about Ted. He fits the Mets fan profile in all the ways. He's from Cleveland on the show, so my writing partner Carter steered Ted's allegiances that way...but something tells me that in his NYC life, Ted was going to Mets games and hoping maybe he'd meet The Mother there (but instead, I did literally that move in my book!).
Have you passed your Mets fandom on to anyone else in your family?
My son has inherited the blessing/curse of Mets fandom. He is such a sincere and true fan with endless patience for crappy seasons like the one we all just witnessed. "They're still my team, Dad!" he says when I am bitching about them. And he's right. They're still my team, too. I'm lucky he reminds me of what a true fan really looks like.
The beginning and end of your podcast are tribute letters (or voice memos) from fans. If you were writing a tribute letter to the Mets, how would it begin?
"Long time fan, first time caller......hey, it's been four decades now, can you please win one more World Series before I die? Thanks!"
You can contact me on Bluesky or via e-mail ([email protected]). You can find my other newsletter, which summarizes interviews I do with journalists, here.

