Got thoughts on the 1986 Mets or this newsletter? Think that 3,400 words on this game is too much or too little? Please reach out to [email protected]

After losing the first game of the World Series the Mets looked to get even the next evening at Shea Stadium. The pitching matchup for Game 2 was one of ace-versus-ace: Dwight Gooden against Roger Clemens.  

NBC's Vin Scully said this was "the greatest pairing since Lunt and Fontanne." I had no idea who he was talking about, so I looked it up.

Per a Google search, "Lynn Fontanne was an English actress. After early success in supporting roles in the West End and United States, she married the American actor Alfred Lunt in 1922, with whom she co-starred in Broadway and West End productions over the next four decades." They were extremely famous and were awarded a Presidential Medal of Freedom in 1964. A Broadway theatre bearing their name recently hosted the musical Death Becomes Her.

Nobel Prize winner Elie Wiesel threw out the ceremonial first pitch. Wiesel was not a baseball fan but was asked to participate by MLB commissioner Peter Ueberroth. Future MLB commish Fay Vincent recounted this in an article about 10 years ago and noted that Wiesel, a Holocaust survivor who wrote many books about his life experiences, did not know what the World Series was but had it explained to him by his son.  "It is an honor to stand alongside him," said NBC's Vin Scully.

Davey Johnson made a couple of interesting lineup choices for Game 2. He started Danny Heep for Mookie Wilson and Howard Johnson for Ray Knight. Scully said it was because both Knight and Wilson were slumping (Knight was 4-for-24 in the postseason, Wilson was 4-for-30, plus Hojo was a great fastball hitter). In both cases the move would have eventual wake-em-up dividends for those who were slumping, but not in this game.

This one lived up to its billing for all of two innings. In the second, home plate umpire Jim Evans had Gooden remove what was apparently a band-aid on his left ring finger. Whether this perturbed Gooden, who had it taped up again when he got back to the dugout, I don't know. But he didn't get good results after that.

The first sign that this was not going to be the Mets day was when Gooden walked shortstop Spike Owen, who hit .138 against right-handed pitching in the regular season.

The second sign was that when the next batter, Clemens, bunted, first baseman Keith Hernandez rushed his throw to shortstop Rafael Santana at second base. It bounced and Santana couldn't field it cleanly. The Red Sox had two on with nobody out.

That opened the floodgates. Hits by Wade Boggs, Marty Barrett, and Bill Buckner produced three runs. The Mets trailed 3-0.

"There was almost a defiant air in New York from the fans particularly," Scully said. "How good the Mets were. They were destiny's darlings. And they were, in some quarters, going to sweep the Red Sox. The Red Sox feel they have some destiny going for them."

The third sign that the Mets weren't going to win this game came in the bottom of the third. The Mets were 4-for-72 in the first three innings of the first eight games of the postseason. They'd break that with three hits, including a Gooden bunt that Buckner dove for and couldn't catch (Scully and Joe Garagiola noted that finally the Mets had tested Buckner on defense).

By the way, Buckner got more praise from the broadcast crew in this game, though not as much as he did in Game 1. When he was later removed for a pinch-runner, Scully said, "He gets a well-deserved round of applause for his gutsy play on a bad leg" to which Garagiola added "And he never complains."

The rally produced two runs and would have netted more if not for the fine defense of Boggs at third base. Boggs had made a big play to save Game 1. Here he made a barehand play of a Wally Backman comebacker that hit Clemens for one out and then dove to rob Gary Carter of the tying hit for the final out of the inning. After three innings the Red Sox led, 3-2.

The fourth reason that it was not to be for the Mets on October 19, 1986, happened two pitches into the fourth inning when Dave Henderson hit a booming home run. Joe Garagiola compared it to the kind of home runs Mets broadcaster Ralph Kiner used to hit. That made it 4-2 Red Sox, and it was all downhill from there.

The Mets had two good cracks at it in the fourth inning. With one man on base, Hojo flied to right on a ball that may have been a home run if not for the swirling winds. Then, with two men on base Gooden grounded out. He then allowed a single and a homer to Dwight Evans at the start of the fifth to make it 6-2 Red Sox.

The Mets had one more legitimate chance with the score 6-3 in the fifth inning. But Steve Crawford, on in relief of an early-exiting Clemens, struck Strawberry out looking and got Heep to ground out to end an eight-pitch at-bat and the inning. For Strawberry, this was his eighth straight postseason game with multiple strikeouts. That's still a postseason record.

One word about Clemens' early exit. He had thrown 370 pitches in three starts in the ALCS, two of those on three days rest. He was hittable in this game. With 40 years of hindsight, I get why Red Sox manager John McNamara started Al Nipper in Game 4 to give his top pitchers extra rest. Eleven-year-old me was a little surprised by it at the time.

In the end, the Mets got drubbed, 9-3 and now trailed in the World Series 2-games-to-none.

One thing that struck me as amusing was that late in the game, a ball was hit along the first base line, and Scully described it as "a little roller up along first." We'd be hearing that phrase again (it would become more famous) a little later in the series.

Red Sox reliever Bob Stanley, got the final nine outs of this one and made some of the Mets hitters look bad against his palmball in the process.

Stanley, a native of Kearney, NJ, grew up a Mets fan, but on this night, he was very much not one of them. I'm sure he envisioned the picture below taking place in a different uniform.

To end the broadcast, we got interviews from a member of both the winning and losing team (I thought that was interesting, you don't see a player from the losing team interviewed nowadays).

NBC sideline reporter Marv Albert asked Carter, "Are you embarrassed by what has taken place here at Shea?"

Carter cited the 1985 Royals, who came back from 2-0 down at home to beat the Cardinals in the World Series last year, and tactfully replied "Not at all. I'm very proud of this ball club."

The Mets headed to Boston down 2 games to none. Back in two days with a Metmorable Game 3.

You can contact me on Bluesky or via e-mail ([email protected]). You can find my other newsletter, which summarizes interviews I do with journalists, here.