Got thoughts on the 1986 Mets or this newsletter? Please reach out to [email protected]

Ok, so holy sht, I rewatched all of Game 5 of the 1986 NLCS and I can't get over what this game was like. It was basically like watching hockey overtime for 12 innings or a pitcher's duel akin to Jack Morris and John Smoltz in the 1991 World Series or Curt Schilling and Roger Clemens in 2001.

This one was a little different from those two because there was a tomorrow for both of these teams whereas in 1991 and 2001, they were playing for a championship. But this was such an epic pitcher's duel. It was just awesome.

And there was the possibility that it wasn't even going to be played that day. Game 5 had already been postponed by rain once and the weather was grim early in the day in Flushing.

But eventually the rain ceased and play they would, with the teams tied two games apiece in the best-of-seven series. The field was muddy and the excess water on the Shea Stadium tarp was dumped on the dirt.  The warning track looked treacherous.

When the Mets took the field there was much less than a full house on hand. There were repeated shots of the subways and fans racing to get to the ballpark. This was a game they would want to see.

Tim McCarver predicted that if Dwight Gooden and Nolan Ryan had their curveballs working, it would be a low-scoring ballgame. Tim was right a lot. He was baseball broadcasting's best first-guesser for a long time.

The other thing was that if the home plate umpire (Joe West) was going to keep calling pitches like this one strikes, the pitchers were gonna have a good day.

The Astros had an early scoring threat against Gooden. They put runners on first and third with nobody out in the second inning. Gooden first struck out Alan Ashby, then got Craig Reynolds to hit a grounder to second base.  The Mets went for the double play and got it, but only because first base umpire Fred Brocklander made an incorrect call at first base.

As ABC's Keith Jackson said, "Whoa, Nellie" (actually he said "That's a pretty big miss.") This was the second straight year that an umpire missed a key call at first base. One could argue that the 1985 World Series was decided by Don Denkinger's errant call at first base in Game 6 between the Cardinals and Royals. This one was pretty big too.

But there was no replay review in 1986, so there was nothing that could be done. We played on.

Anyways, among those who were late to the party were the dudes who ran the K Korner in the upper deck in left field. They showed up around the fifth inning.

That's when the first scoring happened. With first and third and one out, Bill Doran checked his swing on a two-strike pitch and the Mets didn't get the call.

Doran then hit a grounder to second that Backman fielded but had a hard time getting out to Rafael Santana at shortstop. The Mets got the force play but not the double play. A run scored to put the Astros ahead 1-0 going to the bottom of the fifth.

Meanwhile Ryan was dominating. He struck out seven of the first 12 hitters he faced and was perfect for the first 4 1/3 innings. He had a new pitch this season, a tailing fastball that was giving the Mets hitters a lot of trouble.

Ryan fell behind 3-0 on Darryl Strawberry. The next pitch was a strike and the next one was close and called a strike. A fan near ABC's crowd mic yelled "Ball four." Strawberry looked a little perturbed to which McCarver said don't get mad, he could hit a home run. Two pitches later, Strawberry obliged.

Barely. Check out where the ball landed down the right field line.

"This is what happens when you turn around a 94 mph fastball. It goes out like a bullet,"  Jackson said and McCarver gave a little toldyaso to Strawberry. "I ask you. Is a ball that curves around the foul pole better than a walk?"

Yes, it is!!!

That evened things at 1-1 after 5 innings and if that was our initial serving of overtime, everything that followed felt like double and triple overtime.

Ryan's start is an all-timer postseason start. He went nine innings and allowed one run on two hits with 12 strikeouts and 1 walk. He could have easily pitched a no-hitter. It was the first postseason start of that many innings and strikeouts and that few runs, hits, and walks in 80 years. The only one prior to it was by Deadball standout Ed Walsh for the 1906 White Sox against the Cubs. Two pitchers have done it since: Roger Clemens (2000 Yankees vs Mariners) and Tim Lincecum (2010 Giants vs Braves). It was a rare gem.

Gooden wasn't Ryan but he was good when he had to be. Gary Carter helped him out by throwing Kevin Bass out trying to steal in the sixth.

Bill Doran led off the top of the eighth with a hit. There's no chance Gooden would have been left in the game in 2026 but Davey Johnson rode with him and thensome. Billy Hatcher had a rather adventurous sacrifice bunt in which the ball straddled the foul line leaving Keith Hernandez with no choice but to pick it up and tag Hatcher rather than see if it would roll foul.

What happened next doesn't come often in discussions of the 1986 Mets postseason and that's because there's a ton of other things to bring up. But it's essentially the blunder of blunders before Buckner. With Doran on second base and one out, Denny Walling hits a line drive to left field. Keith Jackson channels his inner Chip Caray and immediately says "base hit." But it's not. The ball hangs up and Mookie Wilson catches it eye-high.

Doran meanwhile misread it as badly as Jackson did. He took off running thinking he was going to score.  But instead Wilson flipped the ball to shortstop Rafael Santana for an easy double play. Gooden was out of the inning on four pitches. Had Doran held at second the Astros would have had their best hitter, Glenn Davis, up in a situation in which a hit would put them ahead. Whoops!

The Mets and Astros each went 1-2-3 for the next inning-and-a-half and the score was tied 1-1 after nine innings.

Gooden stayed on for the 10th inning, which was notable because he'd never pitched into the 10th inning before. And there was another big play that is oft-forgotten here. After the first two batters made outs, Terry Puhl pinch-hit for Ryan, reached on an infield single, and stole second. Doran walked, bringing up Billy Hatcher with two on and two outs. Again, Johnson stuck with Gooden as fans nervously watched from outside the No. 7 subway entrance.

On an 0-2 pitch Hatcher hit a fly ball down the right field line that looked like trouble off the bat. But Strawberry raced over to make the catch that kept the score tied.

The next 13 batters in the game made out. The Mets did nothing against Charlie Kerfeld, who looked as dominant as Ryan in the 10th and 11th innings. Carter hit a ball hard but right to Walling who was playing along the third base line. "Nothing is going right for Gary Carter in this series," McCarver said. The Astros didn't do anything against Jesse Orosco either.

The Mets were getting desperate. They resorted to rally caps to try to appease the baseball Gods

Astros manager Hal Lanier stuck with Kerfeld for a third inning in the bottom of the 12th despite having closer Dave Smith available. I suspect he was antsy to use Smith given how the Mets had hit successfully against him a few times, including Len Dykstra's walk-off home run in Game 3.

After Dykstra grounded out, Wally Backman hit a rocket to third base that Walling couldn't handle. This was only the Mets third hit in 37 at-bats in the game. The Astros then blundered again as Kerfeld's pickoff throw was too far to the right field side of first base. It got away from Davis and Backman went to second base. The Astros had Kerfeld walk Hernandez to put runners on first and second for Carter, who was 1-for-21 in the series to that point.

"I doubt there will be a play at the plate" said McCarver, pointing out how deep the Astros were playing, basically conceding a game-winning single. Remember that in Game 3 of the series Kerfeld made a behind-the-back snag of Carter's comebacker, then pointed at Carter as he threw to first base.

Well, sometimes, payback is a b-tch (botch, of course). Carter got ahead 2-0 and Kerfeld nearly hit him with his third pitch. He got strike one and then Carter fouled off three straight pitches.

On Kerfeld's next 3-2, Carter hit a grounder up the middle. Kerfeld's follow-through took him too far to the first base side to make a play on the ball. It rolled into center field for a base hit. Indeed, Billy Hatcher was deep and by the time he got the throw in to home plate, Backman had scored the winning run. The Mets won 2-1 in 12 innings and 2-for-22 never felt so good.

Both teams would fly to Houston with no off day for Game 6 tomorrow. When you combine this game and the next one with the back-to-back Game 4 and Game 5 epics between the Red Sox and Angels (we haven’t talked about those, but those were amazing too), you have arguably the most exciting five-day stretch of postseason baseball that there’s ever been (Got a better one? e-mail me- [email protected])

Here's a series of photos of the Carter hit and the celebration.

This is Gary Carter’s father

Sorry Charlie.

You can contact me on Bluesky or via e-mail ([email protected]). You can find my other newsletter, which summarizes interviews I do with journalists, here.