Got thoughts on the 1986 Mets or this newsletter? Please reach out to [email protected]
As I said, I’m going to recap each game of the 1986 postseason, some in more creative ways than others. Here’s Game 1 …
If I was going to zoom in on one thing from the Astros 1-0 win over the Mets in Game 1, it's not going to be Mike Scuff's 14 strikeouts. I don't have time for cheaters (or alleged ones). But I am happy to salute the defense that both teams played in this game.
If we're going to talk great defense and the 1986 Mets, it always starts with Keith Hernandez. He made one great play in the third inning and Ray Knight made another, keeping the score 1-0 when it could have gotten worse.


The third inning had lots of good plays. Hernandez and Knight were just matching Bill Doran, who made this diving catch on Rafael Santana's line drive in the top of the third.

It's a myth that the Mets couldn't do anything against Scuff. They could have easily scored a couple of runs if not for the Astros defense. With Len Dykstra on first base in the sixth inning, Wally Backman hit a shot to the left field fence, but Jose Cruz retreated to make a difficult catch. Dykstra was on second base when the ball was caught. Had it not been he would have scored to tie the game.

The Mets had a great chance to tie in the ninth inning. With Darryl Strawberry on second, Mookie Wilson hit a hard ground ball in the 3-4 hole. But Glenn Davis, who had homered for the only run of the game, made a diving play to prevent a hit and threw to Scuff covering first base for the out.

The play at first was very close. Mets first base coach Bill Robinson argued that Scuff didn't touch first base but he couldn't change first base umpire Lee Weyer's mind. Knight then struck out to end the game. In one night the Mets invincibility bubble had been popped. They trailed in the series one game to none.
Today's game brought to you by … whatever the fck this is.
Game 2 tomorrow- Bob Ojeda vs Nolan Ryan (and a much more detailed recap)

You can contact me on Bluesky or via e-mail ([email protected]). You can find my other newsletter, which summarizes interviews I do with journalists, here.